Case Study

LTB Order CEL-44407-14 – Eviction for Non-Payment and Persistent Late Rent | Port Credit, ON

Chagpar v. Walsh – Landlord and Tenant Board, November 2014

🕑 Case timeline

Application Date: Date not provided

Hearing Date: November 14, 2014

Order Issued: November 17, 2014

Termination Date: November 28, 2014

Eviction Deadline: November 28, 2014

ℹ️ Case overview

Case Number: CEL-44407-14
Address: APT C, 253 Lakeshore Road East, Port Credit, ON L5G1G8
Form Used: Notice of Termination
Served By: Shaheen Chagpar (Landlord)
Amount Awarded: $1,124.73 + $19.89 per day starting November 18, 2014
Decision In Favor: Landlord (L1 application); Tenant (L2 application partially)
Application Type: Eviction for non-payment of rent, persistent late payment, illegal act, safety impairment, and wilful/negligent damage
RTA Sections: Section 69 – Application for eviction order, Section 83(1)(a) – Relief from eviction with conditions, Section 83(2) – Consideration of disclosed circumstances, Section 74(11) – Motion to set aside eviction order, Section 78 – Application without notice for breach of conditional order, Section 81 – Expiry of eviction order, Section 204(1) – Conditional orders

👥 Parties involved

Landlord: Shaheen Chagpar
Landlord Rep: Self Represented
Tenant: David Walsh
Tenant Rep: Self Represented
Adjudicator: Ieva Martin
Keywords: non-payment of rent, persistent late payment, eviction, illegal act, wilful damage, safety impairment, rent arrears, conditional order

⚖️ Decision summary

Tenancy terminated effective November 28, 2014, unless tenant voids the order.
Tenant ordered to pay $954.73 in arrears and compensation up to November 17, 2014, plus $170.00 filing fee.
Daily compensation of $19.89 applies from November 18, 2014 until the unit is vacated.
Eviction void if tenant pays $1,380.00 on or before November 28, 2014.
If L1 is voided, tenancy continues conditionally: rent must be paid on or before the 1st of each month from December 2014 to November 2015.
Failure to comply with conditional payment schedule allows landlord to apply under s.78 without notice.

⚠️ Dispute summary

Landlord filed L1 for non-payment of rent covering October–November 2014.
Landlord filed L2 alleging illegal act, safety impairment, wilful/negligent damage, and persistent late payment.
Tenant testified that changes to the unit were made at the request of the previous owner.
Landlord could not produce the previous owner to testify, undermining damage and safety claims.

📑 Findings & determinations

Tenant did not pay rent for October 1 to November 30, 2014; arrears established under L1 application.
Landlord failed to prove illegal act was committed by tenant, occupant, or permitted person.
Landlord failed to prove tenant wilfully or negligently damaged the rental unit.
Landlord failed to prove changes to the unit seriously impaired the safety of any person.
Tenant found to have persistently failed to pay rent on time since July 2014.

💡 Summary points

Tenant failed to pay rent for October 1 to November 30, 2014, resulting in arrears of $1,210.00.
Landlord's claims of illegal act, wilful damage, and safety impairment were not proven on evidence.
Tenant found to have persistently paid rent late since landlord purchased property in July 2014.
Tenant may void eviction by paying $1,380.00 on or before November 28, 2014.
If tenancy continues, tenant must pay rent on time every month from December 2014 to November 2015.
📄 View Official PDF

Share this case